P17 "was motivation of (motivated)" and "P15 took into account" seem to share some meaning. This should be clarified.
I propose a new and more general property:
Pnn Activity - was influenced by (influenced) Persistent Item
This would subsume:
P15 Activity - took into account (was taken into account by) ConceptualObject
P17 Activity - was motivated by (motivated) Man-Made Stuff (why notStuff?) (issue 79)
It would also resolve issue 79: Change Property Name P17 was motivation
for to was motivated by
TG 23/6/2002
redefine range of:
P15 Activity - took into account (was taken into account by): Persistent Item
I take "took into account" as synonym to "influenced by", as the Actor of the
activity "must let it influence her/him".
redefine range of:
P17 Activity - was motivated by (motivated): Stuff ,
declare P16,P17 as subproperty of P15.
This complements the existing links:
P19 Activity - was intended use of (was made for) Man-Made Stuff
P16 Activity - used specific object (was used for) Stuff (issue 96)
I propose to either add:
Pxx Activity - was influenced by (influenced): E7 Activity
and declare
P18 Activity - was motivation of (motivated) : E7 Activity subproperty of Pxx
Or to generalize P18 into "was influenced by".
The link P20 corresponds to P19:
P20 Activity - had specific purpose (was purpose of) : E7 Activity (intention, future)
Do we need an equivalent to P16 ?:
Pyy Activity - continued (was continued by) : E7 Activity
To my understanding, this is all that could be said about
influence between activity and stuff, and between activities.
It seems to me complete and symmetric.
MD 26/6/2002
P15 Activity was influenced by (influenced) E1 Entity
P17 Activity was motivated by (motivated) E1 Entity
P19 Activity was intended use of (was made for) Man-made Stuff
P16 Activity used specific object (was used for) Stuff
P20 Activity had specific purpose (was purpose of) E7 Activity
Pxx Activity continued (was continued for ) E7 Activity
Delete P18 Activity was motivation of (motivated) E1 Entity because it is subsumed by P17.
P16, P17, P19, P20 and Pxx are sub-properties of P15.
Scope note comment (for Pxx): If one activity is continued by another it would be possible to regard both activities as part of a larger one.
Proposal accepted, Copenhagen 3/7/2002.