In the 61st joint meeting of the CIDOC CRM and ISO/TC46/SC4/WG9 & 54th FRBR/LRMoo SIG, the group resolved to start a new issue as it was discussing the purported relation of E13 Attribute Assignment and P141 assgned (was assigned by) to E15 Identifier Assignment and P38 deassigned (was deassigned by), which had already been declared as non-standing at the 60th SIG meeting.
The motivation behind this proposal was that it may be the case for some instances of E41 Appellation that they are also instances of E42 Identifier (and thus have been assigned by an instance of E15 Identifier Assignment), but this does not apply to all instances of E41 Appellation.
The SIG did not vote on the proposal, because it was made during the meeting.
Heraklion, October 2025
Post by Wolfgang Schmidle (26 February 2025)
Dear All,
In my view, issue 715
is based on a misunderstanding about what the different ranges E41 Appellation of P1 and E42 Identifier of P37 mean for the shortcut. I think the shortcut is fine and issue 715 can be closed.
Best,
Wolfgang