Issue 70: Relationship between P15 took into account and P17 was motivation for
P17 "was motivation of (motivated)" and "P15 took into account" seem to share some meaning. This should be clarified.
I propose a new and more general property:
Pnn Activity - was influenced by (influenced) Persistent Item
This would subsume:
P15 Activity - took into account (was taken into account by) ConceptualObject
P17 Activity - was motivated by (motivated) Man-Made Stuff (why notStuff?) (issue 79)
It would also resolve issue 79: Change Property Name P17 was motivation
for to was motivated by
redefine range of:
P15 Activity - took into account (was taken into account by): Persistent Item
I take "took into account" as synonym to "influenced by", as the Actor of the
activity "must let it influence her/him".
redefine range of:
P17 Activity - was motivated by (motivated): Stuff ,
declare P16,P17 as subproperty of P15.
This complements the existing links:
P19 Activity - was intended use of (was made for) Man-Made Stuff
P16 Activity - used specific object (was used for) Stuff (issue 96)
I propose to either add:
Pxx Activity - was influenced by (influenced): E7 Activity
P18 Activity - was motivation of (motivated) : E7 Activity subproperty of Pxx
Or to generalize P18 into "was influenced by".
The link P20 corresponds to P19:
P20 Activity - had specific purpose (was purpose of) : E7 Activity (intention, future)
Do we need an equivalent to P16 ?:
Pyy Activity - continued (was continued by) : E7 Activity
To my understanding, this is all that could be said about
influence between activity and stuff, and between activities.
It seems to me complete and symmetric.
P15 Activity was influenced by (influenced) E1 Entity
P17 Activity was motivated by (motivated) E1 Entity
P19 Activity was intended use of (was made for) Man-made Stuff
P16 Activity used specific object (was used for) Stuff
P20 Activity had specific purpose (was purpose of) E7 Activity
Pxx Activity continued (was continued for ) E7 Activity
Delete P18 Activity was motivation of (motivated) E1 Entity because it is subsumed by P17.
P16, P17, P19, P20 and Pxx are sub-properties of P15.
Scope note comment (for Pxx): If one activity is continued by another it would be possible to regard both activities as part of a larger one.
Proposal accepted, Copenhagen 3/7/2002.