Issue 630: Redraft the scope note of P38 deassigned

ID: 
630
Starting Date: 
2023-01-19
Working Group: 
3
Status: 
Open
Background: 

In the 55th joint meeting of the CIDOC CRM and SO/TC46/SC4/WG9; 48th FRBR/LRMoo SIG meeting, upon discussing issue 615, the SIG resolved to start a new issue regarding the redrafting of the scope note for P38. Things to consider: 

  • “Deassigning an attribute” (i.e., a property extending to the superclass of E15 Identifier Assignment) would mark one of two possible situations: 
    • a change of opinion re. some property/feature of a thing, 
    • making a statement that a particular proposition is not the case. 
  • Deassigning identifiers on the other hand stands for a common practice in museum documentation that refers to the procedure of removing an identifier form an object. In that sense, it does not document a change of opinion; rather, it states that the particular identifier has become obsolete/is no longer in use.

HW: MD, WS, SdS
 

Belval, December 2022

Reference to Cidoc Version:
Version 7.2.2
Related Entities:
E15 Identifier Assignment, E42 Identifier
Related Properties:
P38 deassigned, P38i was deassigned by

Reference to Issues:

615
scope note of E13 Attribute Assignment

Meetings discussed:

55th CIDOC CRM and 48th FRBR CRM