Issue 14: How to model 'subjects'

Starting Date: 
2001-07-05
Working Group: 
1
Status: 
Done
Closing Date: 
2002-07-02
Background: 

This should also comprise how to model depiction of a group, former issue 32.

Old Proposal: 

In scope: 
See : http://www.cs.vassar.edu/faculty/welty/papers/subjects/subject.html
This paper describes 4 alternative models, which are compliant with the CRM methodology.

IFLA FRBR, Subject Relationships:

The "has as subject" relationship indicates that any of the entities in the model, including work itself, may be the subject of a work. Stated in slightly different terms, the relationship indicates that a work may be about a concept, an object, an event, or place; it may be about a person or corporate body; it may be about an expression, a manifestation, or an item; it may be about another work. The logical connection between a work and a related subject entity serves as the basis both for identifying the subject of an individual work and for ensuring that all works relevant to a given subject are linked to that subject.

Patrick LeBoeuf distinguishes:

The analysis (and indexing) of fine arts museum objects might result into 2 kinds of relationships:
1) "ofness" relationships vs. "aboutness" relationships
2) Erwin Panofsky's categorizations: "pre-iconographic" indexing 
"iconographic" indexing / "iconologic" indexing.

As I tried to explain in my paper, librarians have constantly mistaken "object" relationships for "subject" relationships; as long as they only dealt with books, it was not very problematic, but from the moment they strove to catalog still pictures and objects the same way, the whole thing became an indescribable mess... I think librarians shouldn't pass on this mess to the CRM community!"

Proposal, Monterey Feb. 2002:

The CIDOC CRM should model only the aboutness relationship.

Should be covered by decision on P67 refers to, issue 86

Current Proposal: 

Create new link E 28 Conceptual Object: is about E1 CRM Entity, sub property of P67

MD 20/6/2002

Outcome: 

Proposal 1: The CIDOC CRM should model only the aboutness relationship. Should be covered by decision on P67 refers to (see Issue 86). Decision: Proposal rejected

Proposal 2: Create new link E73 Information Object: is about (is subject of) E1 CRM Entity, sub-property of P67. 

Proposal accepted, Copenhagen 2/7/2002.